www.shinedown.com    Shinedown Forums    Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Shinedown Land  Hop To Forums  If You Only Knew    LAW, UAT,or TSOM
Page 1 2 

Moderators: Barry

Closed Poll Closed
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
-star Rating Rate It!  Login/Join 
•¦м¦Φ¦®¦ï¦Ð¦•
Picture of •¦м¦Φ¦®¦ï¦Ð¦•
Posted
Just wondering... I'll vote on the 24th

Question:
Which Shinedown CD is your favorite

Choices:
Leave A Whisper
Us and Them
The Sound of Madness

 


______Morid_______
''I'm just a guy with a guitar...'' -Jasin Todd
 
Posts: 287 | Location: In nowhere, I found out where it is (Egypt) | Registered: 30 August 2007Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
<I4C>
Posted
Leave a Whisper hands down. LAW is creative, raw, real, and perfect.
Even though I love UAT; there are sum serously fucked up things about it...sum with the record itself, but mostly with what went on behind the scenes.
I love this record too, but Sound of Madness is a commercial record designed to make money; art takes second place to riches and fame on this record.
If the fucking assholes, you know who you are, had left SD alone, both of these records would have been just as amazing as the first. SD had nothing to lose with LAW, so it's pure SD; the others are tainted big time.
This is of course, IMHO (in my humble opinion).
)O(-D.
 
Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
•¦м¦Φ¦®¦ï¦Ð¦•
Picture of •¦м¦Φ¦®¦ï¦Ð¦•
Posted Hide Post
I didn't listen to the Sound of Madness and all the people who listened to it say it's awesome. My brother says it is better than UAT and LAW and all Alter Bridge CD's (because Shinedown and Alter Bridge are my favorite bands). But I agree with you that LAW is Shinedown, you can feel that it is Shinedown but I am happy because of the change.


______Morid_______
''I'm just a guy with a guitar...'' -Jasin Todd
 
Posts: 287 | Location: In nowhere, I found out where it is (Egypt) | Registered: 30 August 2007Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
shinedown2237
Posted Hide Post
YOU FORGOT ALL 3 AS A CHOICE. BECAUSE SHINEDOWN AS MY FAVORITE BAND I LOVE ALL 3 THE SAME JUST LIKE I LOVE MY KIDS ALL THE SAME.
 
Posts: 17 | Registered: 29 August 2007Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Jt13
Posted Hide Post
Its hard for me. Yesterday i went out and bought LAW cd agian because i never got the hard copy, just itunes version...i played it on the way home and i was just amazed on how good that CD really is. There is only one song where i could say i did not really care for, with SOM its the same thing. They are different CD's and great for their own reason. Therefore i like both CD different for different reasons and i cant really chose.
 
Posts: 63 | Registered: 23 January 2008Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
tmaj
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by shinedown2237:
YOU FORGOT ALL 3 AS A CHOICE. BECAUSE SHINEDOWN AS MY FAVORITE BAND I LOVE ALL 3 THE SAME JUST LIKE I LOVE MY KIDS ALL THE SAME.

Why are you shouting?


I chose LAW, for reasons already mentioned.

Sound of Madness is good, but there are a couple of songs that are way overproduced. Devour just seems like a waste of Brent's vocal ability to me, and If You Only Knew seems really generic as well. The only way I see them topping LAW in the future is if they make it really big, drop the record label, and start making music just for the hell of it instead of trying to sell cds. I'm not criticizing them for making the decisions thev're made, because I would do the same, but it just isn't what's best from an artistic standpoint.
 
Posts: 19 | Location: Wisco baby!! | Registered: 04 February 2008Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Dan C
Posted Hide Post
LaW. Near impossible to beat, IMO.
 
Posts: 56 | Location: Iowa | Registered: 12 June 2007Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
sexpanth3r
Posted Hide Post
devour was a fuckn awesome song..and trust me..it was not a waste of his vocal ability..there are some hard notes to hit in that song..the sound of madness is the best..hands down!!
 
Posts: 13 | Registered: 18 June 2008Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Wheres the conviction
Posted Hide Post
It was pretty much a tie for me between law and tsom. I personally think devour should not have made the cut and been replaced by junkies for fame. Out of all 3cds INCLUDING bonus tracks so far Devour is the worst track!


Thank you for the venom. Did you think it would paralyze?
 
Posts: 32 | Registered: 07 May 2008Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
1 crazy mama
Picture of 1 crazy mama
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by I4C:
Leave a Whisper hands down. LAW is creative, raw, real, and perfect.
Even though I love UAT; there are sum serously fucked up things about it...sum with the record itself, but mostly with what went on behind the scenes.
I love this record too, but Sound of Madness is a commercial record designed to make money; art takes second place to riches and fame on this record.
If the fucking assholes, you know who you are, had left SD alone, both of these records would have been just as amazing as the first. SD had nothing to lose with LAW, so it's pure SD; the others are tainted big time.
This is of course, IMHO (in my humble opinion).
)O(-D.

I must say, I agree with you 100%. Of course, this is also IMHO!! Wink


We love you, Jasin! " You set me up to fucking fail this time!"
We love you, Brad!



http://myspace.com/sdluvinmama
 
Posts: 363 | Location: alpharetta, ga. | Registered: 07 July 2007Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
<I4C>
Posted
quote:
The only way I see them topping LAW in the future is if they make it really big, drop the record label, and start making music just for the hell of it instead of trying to sell cds.


Amen. With LAW, four fantastically talented musicians did it their way. This is why Leave A Whisper is such a stellar record. Even the record title is way above and beyond belief, and 7 years later everything about this record, the cover design, the lyrics, the guitar, the drums, the bass, the vocals, the soul, still amazes me. And the live shows during the LAW tour literally transported us to another reality. It really fucking changed my life and I will always be deeply greatful for that no matter what happens in the future.
)O(-D.
 
Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
pbh45
Picture of pbh45
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by I4C:
quote:
The only way I see them topping LAW in the future is if they make it really big, drop the record label, and start making music just for the hell of it instead of trying to sell cds.


Amen. With LAW, four fantastically talented musicians did it their way. This is why Leave A Whisper is such a stellar record. Even the record title is way above and beyond belief, and 7 years later everything about this record, the cover design, the lyrics, the guitar, the drums, the bass, the vocals, the soul, still amazes me. And the live shows during the LAW tour literally transported us to another reality. It really fucking changed my life and I will always be deeply greatful for that no matter what happens in the future.
)O(-D.
quote:



That is so true Donna. LAW takes me back so much. I guess I was in a really dark time in my life when that record dropped. And the tour from that album, oh my god. I can still in my mind watch those shows that I witnessed in my mind. too amazing!


__________________________________________________

"Even though I Might SEEM SMALL know this my mind is a weapon" Brent Smith


"I never heard such a haunting melody"
 
Posts: 787 | Location: Memphis, TN | Registered: 10 October 2005Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
LEESA es inocente
2+2=5
what she said...
Picture of LEESA es inocente
Posted Hide Post
easy choice for fave - LAW. i doubt TSOM will change my mind on this one.


Amaru - Society Red - God Or Julie -Captain Kid -Skindred -Christina Perri -Cinder Road
~check these bands/artists out. put your cursor over the name and enlighten yourself Smiler

i know my way around...

The best story I ever read
 
Posts: 490 | Location: Siokayahwalah, FL ---"THE one AND only." | Registered: 10 October 2005Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Jdanek630
Posted Hide Post
Wow, I guess I'm not the only one who doesn't show as much love for UAT as I/we do for LAW and TSOM huh?? Well, it's good to know that I'm certainly not alone.
 
Posts: 26 | Location: Holyoke, MA | Registered: 15 April 2008Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Die2Win86
Posted Hide Post
I still like LAW the best, because it was the cd that got me into the band in the first place, not to mention it was flawless.

First impressions are ever lasting I guess.


____________________________________________________________________________________________________
 
Posts: 38 | Location: Modesto, CA | Registered: 18 April 2008Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community Page 1 2  

Closed Poll Closed
www.shinedown.com    Shinedown Forums    Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Shinedown Land  Hop To Forums  If You Only Knew    LAW, UAT,or TSOM