I'm surprised no one has said anything about this show. I was there and it was amazing. I didn't write down the setlist but this is what I can remember (not in exact order):

Steadier Footing
We Will Become Silhouettes
Photobooth
Title and Registration
Movie Script Ending
Cover Song (not sure what this was but a lot of people were singing along)
Why You'd Want to Live Here
You Remind Me of Home
Crooked Teeth
We Looked Like Giants
Soul Meets Body
Passenger Seat
Squeeze? cover (didn't catch the title but some girl requested it and ben dedicated the song to her)
405
A Lack of Color
Brand New Colony
I'll Follow You Into the Dark
Blacking Out the Friction
All Apologies
Sound of Settling
Such Great Heights

Great show, crowd was okay...not a ton of talking but enough for it to get kind of annoying at times. Oh, and before he played a Lack of Color he asked the bartender to please refrain from throwing glass bottles onto other glass bottles for the next three minutes which I am glad he did, that was really annoying!

All in all a great show, I wish I could have gone down to Austin to see him the next night!